Keith P. Reynolds of Middletown, N.Y. was born in the Bronx and raised in Congers. He is the eldest of two brothers born to Kevin and Holly Reynolds. Keith is married to Janice (nee Boyle) and they have three children: Jessica, Matthew and Keira. Keith traces his Irish heritage through his grandparents who emigrated from Counties Meath and Cavan. He attended SUNY Rockland and served in the United States Marine Corps Reserves.
Keith began his law enforcement career as a police officer with the Greenwood Lake Police Department. Three years later, he graduated the F.B.I. Firearms Instructors School at Camp Smith, and quickly became the department’s Senior Firearms and Training Officer. Keith served as the department’s Field Intelligence Officer, and Dive Team Leader on the department’s Dive Rescue Team. He was promoted to the ranks of Corporal in 2001 and Sergeant in 2005. Keith received numerous commendations and awards throughout his police career, including the Medal of Honor. After retiring from the Greenwood Lake Police Department in 2012, he joined the Town of Deerpark Police Department and served as the Firearms and Training Officer until 2017.
Keith is a proud member and Past President of the AOH Joseph Duelk Jr. Division 1 in Monroe, and was the past New York State AOH Organizer and District 8 Director. He is also a member of the Pine Bush Knights of Columbus and a member of the Police Emerald Society of the Hudson Valley. Keith has served his community in numerous roles including, past Director of the Mid Hudson St Patrick’s Day Parade Committee, former Bass Drummer with the Orange County AOH Division 1 Pipes and Drums, and was 1st Lieutenant with the Pine Island Volunteer Fire Department until 2009.